Southern Medical Journal 2010 (Aug); 103 (8): 738–747 ~ FULL TEXT
Brenda Breuer, PhD, MPH, Ricardo Cruciani, MD, PhD, Russell K. Portenoy, MD
Department of Pain Medicine and Palliative Care,
Beth Israel Medical Center,
New York, NY 10003, USA.
OBJECTIVES: Chronic pain is a serious public health problem and is treated by diverse health care providers. In order to enhance policies and programs to improve pain care, we collected information about the distribution of pain patients among four major groups of pain management providers: primary care physicians (PCPs), pain physicians, chiropractors, and acupuncturists, and the variation in the attitudes and practices of these providers with respect to some common strategies used for pain.
METHODS: National mail survey of PCPs, pain physicians, chiropractors, and acupuncturists (ntotal = 3,000).
RESULTS: Eight hundred seventeen responses were usable (response rate, 29%).
Analyses weighted to obtain nationally representative data showed that:
PCPs treat approximately 52% of chronic pain patients
chiropractors treat 40%
acupuncturists treat 7%
pain physicians treat 2%
Of the chronic pain patients seen for evaluation, the percentages subsequently treated on an ongoing basis range from 51% (PCPs) to 63% (pain physicians). Pain physicians prescribe long-acting opioids such as methadone, antidepressants or anti-convulsants, and other nontraditional analgesics approximately 50-100% more often than PCPs. Twenty-nine percent of PCPs and 16% of pain physicians reported prescribing opioids less often than they deem appropriate because of regulatory oversight concerns. Of the four groups, PCPs are least likely to feel confident in their ability to manage musculoskeletal pain and neuropathic pain, and are least likely to favor mandatory pain education for all PCPs.
CONCLUSIONS: There is substantial variation in attitudes and practices of the various disciplines that treat chronic pain. This information may be useful in interpreting differences in patient access to pain care, planning studies to clarify patient outcomes in relation to different providers and treatment strategies, and designing a system that matches chronic pain patients to appropriate practitioners and treatments.
Chronic pain is highly prevalent, and is costly in terms of lost productivity.
Primary care physicians, pain physicians, chiropractors, and acupuncturists
vary in the way they treat chronic pain, and in their attitudes
regarding such treatment.
These variations underscore the need for planning studies that relate
patient outcomes to different provider groups and treatments,
and designing a system that matches patients to
practitioners and treatments.
Return to the SPINAL PAIN MANAGEMENT Page