JAMA 2003 (Dec 3); 290 (21): 2824–2830 ~ FULL TEXT
Taylor JA, Weber W, Standish L, Quinn H, Goesling J,
McGann M, Calabrese C
Child Health Institute,
University of Washington and Children's Hospital and Regional Medical Center,
Depending upon how you interpret a study, echinacea may — or may not — be effective in reducing the severity of upper respiratory tract infections in children, according to a study in the Dec. 3 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).
Echinacea is an herb commonly used by adults for the prevention and treatment of upper respiratory infections in adults. According to the study, the average child gets six to eight colds each year, with each lasting seven to nine days.
James A. Taylor, MD, from the University of Washington, Seattle, and his colleagues conducted a randomized controlled trial to determine the effectiveness and safety of Echinacea purpurea in treating URIs in children two to 11 years old. The authors said there was no difference in duration between upper respiratory tract infections treated with echinacea or a placebo. Nor was there a statistically significant difference between the two groups for peak severity of symptoms, number of days of peak symptoms, number of days of fever or parental global assessment of severity of the URI.
However, the press release from JAMA failed to mention that the children in the echinacea group experienced significantly fewer second and third upper respiratory tract infections than children in the placebo group during the four-month trial, according Mark Blumenthal, founder and executive director of the American Botanical Council, a nonprofit research and education organization concerning herbs and medicinal plants.
The study’s authors state, “It is conceivable that Echinacea stimulated an immune response in study children that was too late to modify the URI for which it was given but provided a window of protection against another URI in the child.” These findings were not listed in the trials’ primary outcomes.
CONTEXT: Echinacea is a widely used herbal remedy for treatment of upper respiratory tract infections (URIs). However, there are few data on the efficacy and safety of echinacea in treating URIs in children.
OBJECTIVES: To determine if Echinacea purpurea is effective in reducing the duration and/or severity of URI symptoms in children and to assess its safety in this population.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of healthy children 2 to 11 years old recruited from a regional practice-based network and an alternative medical center in 4-month periods from 2000 through 2002.
INTERVENTIONS: Study patients were randomized to receive either echinacea or placebo for up to 3 URIs over a 4-month period. Study medication was begun at the onset of symptoms and continued throughout the URI, for a maximum of 10 days.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Primary outcomes were duration and severity of symptoms and adverse events recorded by parents; secondary outcomes included peak severity of symptoms, number of days of peak severity, number of days of fever, and a global assessment of severity of symptoms by parents of study children.
RESULTS: Data were analyzed on 707 URIs that occurred in 407 children, including 337 URIs treated with echinacea and 370 with placebo. There were 79 children who completed their study period without having a URI. The median duration of URIs was 9 days (95% confidence interval, 8-10 days); there was no difference in duration between URIs treated with echinacea or placebo (P =.89). There was also no difference in the overall estimate of severity of URI symptoms between the 2 treatment groups (median, 33 in both groups; P =.69). In addition, there were no statistically significant differences between the 2 groups for peak severity of symptoms (P =.68), number of days of peak symptoms (1.60 in the echinacea group and 1.64 in the placebo group; P =.97), number of days of fever (0.81 in the echinacea group vs 0.64 in the placebo group; P =.09), or parental global assessment of severity of the URI (P =.67). Overall, there was no difference in the rate of adverse events reported in the 2 treatment groups; however, rash occurred during 7.1% of the URIs treated with echinacea and 2.7% of those treated with placebo (P =.008).
CONCLUSIONS: Echinacea purpurea, as dosed in this study, was not effective in treating URI symptoms in patients 2 to 11 years old, and its use was associated with an increased risk of rash.
Return to the ECHINACEA Page