Spine (Phila Pa 1976) 1999 (Nov 1); 24 (21): 2262–2267
Grimmer KA, Williams MT, Gill TK
University of South Australia,
STUDY DESIGN: A Cross-sectional, observational study, examining the effects of backpack weight on adolescent posture.
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the response of the craniovertebral angle to backpack load.
SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: There is a widely held belief that repeated carrying of heavy loads, such as school backpacks, places additional stress on rapidly growing adolescent spinal structures, making them prone to postural change.
METHODS: Ten volunteer state high schools in metropolitan Adelaide, South Australia, provided 985 students, aged 12 to 18 years and from five different high school years, for this study. Students' posture was measured with and without their school backpack. All data analyses were undertaken per school year level to account for specific load-carrying requirements and spinal development associated with the age group.
RESULTS: A significant change in craniovertebral angle was found at every year level, when comparing standing posture with no backpack with posture when carrying a backpack. The change was greatest for the youngest students. Incremental change in craniovertebral angle was not strongly associated with backpack loads. The association became stronger for the oldest girls when controlled for body mass index and for weight.
CONCLUSION: The results support a differential postural response per gender and per level of spinal development but also suggest that the craniovertebral angle may not be the most sensitive measure of head-on-neck postural change for adolescents.